Search
A compact traditional dining nook with an oak table, upholstered chairs and a cushioned window seat overlooking a late-autumn yard.

Downsizing in Geneva: What a Smaller Home Costs Here

November 19, 2026

On Nov. 3, a single-story house on South Street in Geneva sold for $885,000. It was built in 1921 and has 2,020 square feet, three bedrooms and three bathrooms on a 7,405-square-foot lot. The price works out to $438 per square foot, as Shaw Local reported.

In the closing week of October, a four-bedroom, four-bathroom house on Bealer Circle sold for $920,000. That house has 4,135 square feet, so the price came to $222 per square foot, according to Shaw Local's Kane County property transfers for Oct. 26 to Nov. 1.

The two prices are $35,000 apart. One house has twice the floor space of the other. For a long-time Geneva owner thinking about a smaller home, that pair of sales sums up the math. You give up space much faster than you give up price, and a one-floor layout is the most expensive thing to find.

Bigger Houses Sell for Less per Foot Here

The Bealer Circle sale was not unusual. Here are the other Geneva single-family sales Shaw Local recorded for that same late-October week:

  • Shannon Square: $578,000, 2,183 square feet, $265 per square foot
  • Le Baron Court: $528,500, 2,205 square feet, $240 per square foot
  • Pepper Valley Drive: $485,000, 2,128 square feet, $228 per square foot

All three are four-bedroom, three-bathroom houses. A week earlier, a three-bedroom house on Dooley Drive sold for $430,000, which is $230 per square foot on 1,871 square feet (Shaw Local, Oct. 19–25 transfers).

So this fall's family-sized Geneva houses mostly sold between about $220 and $265 per square foot. The single-story house on South Street sold for well above that. Part of that gap is location and age, since this is a 1921 house on an older in-town lot. It is also a single-level home with three bedrooms on a lot of about 7,400 square feet. A downsizer who sells a large four-bedroom house is selling at the lower end of that per-foot range and buying at the higher end.

The Newest Smaller Homes Have Three Floors

The new-construction option in Geneva right now is Geneva Crossing. It's Lexington Homes' community of 40 townhomes at 2763 Stone Circle, just west of Randall Road. When the models opened, the Daily Herald described the plans as three-level townhouses with 1,780 to 2,278 square feet.

These prices come from Lexington's Geneva Crossing page as of mid-November 2026:

Plan Bedrooms Square feet Listed from Per square foot
Orchid 2–3 1,780 $536,220 about $301
Lotus 3–4 1,954 $484,990 about $248
Juniper 3–4 2,278 $549,990 about $241

The smallest plan, the Orchid, costs the most per foot. A quick move-in Lotus at 2701 Stone Circle is listed at $526,695 and marked available in December 2026, which works out to about $270 per square foot. Builder pricing changes often, so treat these numbers as a mid-November snapshot.

The pattern from the resale side shows up here too. Smaller costs more per foot. These townhomes come with two-car garages and an attached-home setup. They also come with stairs, because they are built over three levels. For a buyer whose main reason for moving is to live on one floor, the newest smaller homes in Geneva don't solve that.

One-Floor Townhomes Approved for Peck Road

The City of Geneva has already said it wants that missing kind of home. Prairie Grove was proposed for 5.75 acres of vacant land at 1N557 Peck Road. The plan calls for 24 townhomes: 20 ranch-style homes with two or three bedrooms and four two-story homes with three bedrooms. Each home would have a two-car garage, according to Tri-Cities Central. At the Jan. 9, 2025 Planning and Zoning Commission hearing, the applicant described it as a maintenance-free community with an HOA, and the commission minutes record that commissioners agreed Geneva needs this type of product.

On Jan. 21, 2025, the City Council voted 9–0 to approve the zoning change and the subdivision plat. According to the Kane County Reporter's account of the meeting, Ald. Mike Bruno said he was pleased these are one-floor homes and that it is important to create these types of housing options.

For a downsizer making plans this winter, Prairie Grove is an approved plan to keep watching. It is the clearest sign of where single-level supply in Geneva could come from. Until homes there are actually for sale, though, it doesn't add to the choices a seller has today.

Downtown's Next Residential Site Is Still Under Review

The other project worth tracking is at the former Mill Race Inn site, 4 E. State St. On Sept. 16, 2026, Shodeen filed plans for Mill Race Residences: 84 units in three five-story buildings on 1.82 acres. The site includes the former cycle-shop parcel at 12 E. State St., according to Shaw Local. In that same September report, Shodeen had not decided whether the units would be condos for sale or apartments for rent. As of Shaw Local's Oct. 30 report, the proposal was still under staff review.

For a downsizer who wants to stay in the middle of town, the open question is whether these 84 units will be homes someone can buy or apartments to rent.

The Shortage Extends Across Kane County

Geneva's situation is part of a county-wide pattern. Kane County's Housing Readiness Action Plan, adopted by the County Board on June 9, 2026, describes the county as limited in the variety of its housing, with 69 percent of homes being single-family. The same plan says demand for housing options for residents over 55 is already high and expected to grow.

When most homes are large single-family houses and demand for smaller, simpler homes keeps growing, the smaller homes command a premium per foot. This fall's Geneva sales and the Geneva Crossing price list both reflect that.

Selling the Big House Is the Easier Half

The house you're leaving is the part of the move you control best. The REALTOR Association of the Fox Valley's October 2026 report shows Kane County had 882 active listings, 1.8 months of inventory and an average of 39 days on market in October. These are county-wide figures, not Geneva's alone. At that pace, a well-presented four-bedroom house in Geneva can often find a buyer faster than its owner can find the right smaller home.

That puts the planning work on the buying side. Here are three things to settle before you list:

  1. Which you need more: one level or new construction. The South Street sale shows what an older single-story house in town brings. Geneva Crossing has new construction, but with stairs.
  2. How long you can wait for new supply. The council approved Prairie Grove in January 2025, and Mill Race Residences was filed in September 2026. If either one fits your plans, how long you can wait decides whether you buy now or rent for a while after selling.
  3. What your house nets against a smaller home's price. In this fall's sales, a large house sold for roughly the same price as a small single-story one. That means a downsize may free up less equity than many owners expect. Run the numbers on both homes before deciding the order of the move.

Our selling and buying at the same time post covers the timing side. Our staging program is built to get the most for the larger house you're leaving. For more on the town itself, see our Geneva neighborhood guide.

If you're weighing a smaller home in Geneva, Holzl Homes can start with the number that matters most: what your current house will bring in today's market, compared side by side with what the one-floor homes in town actually cost. Request your free home valuation, and we'll work out both halves of the move with you.

Follow Us On Instagram